2026 Agency Roundup · Roofing PPC + LSA

The 8 Best Google Ads & LSA Agencies for Roofers in 2026

Real pricing where published. Real contract terms. Real LSA dispute filing data. 8 agencies compared on 14 criteria that matter for an roofing contractor hiring a marketing partner. Independently researched from public sources, BBB filings, agency websites, and 700+ roofing-account benchmarks.

Last verified: May 19, 2026 · Reviewed quarterly
8
roofing marketing agencies compared
14
Evaluation criteria per agency
$750–$25K
Monthly fee range across agencies
3 of 8
Publish pricing transparently online
How We Evaluated

Criteria Picked for Roofing Economics, Not Generic Agency Vetting

Most "best roofing agency" listicles use the same checklist they use for plumbers, electricians, and HVAC: pricing, team size, case studies. That misses what actually drives roofing ROAS. We picked 14 criteria specifically because they predict roofing outcomes: dispute filing volume (roofing has the highest dispute rate of any home services trade), storm event response speed, retail vs storm campaign separation, insurance claim quality, and aerial measurement integrations. Blue Grid Media publishes this comparison and ranks itself first. Criteria were locked before any agency was scored.

Disclosure: Blue Grid Media is one of the agencies evaluated. Our 14 criteria are weighted toward what makes a roofing account profitable, not what a generic home services agency wants you to compare on. We do not accept payment from agencies for inclusion, placement, or favorable scoring. Each agency was scored using publicly available information from their website, Clutch.co profiles, BBB filings, G2 reviews, and press releases. If you see a factual error in any agency's row, email it via /contact and we will verify within 5 business days.

The 14 criteria, with roofing weighting

  • Pricing transparency (published rate card vs quote-only)
  • Pricing model (flat fee vs % of ad spend)
  • Setup fees (deal-breaker for storm-season cash-flow timing)
  • Contract length (matters more for trades with seasonal volatility)
  • Free trial / money-back guarantee
  • Roofing specialization depth (case study volume + trade focus %)
  • Google Ads management quality (storm + retail campaign structure)
  • LSA management depth (heaviest dispute volume of any trade)
  • LSA dispute filing policy (typically $500–$1,500/mo recoverable)
  • Google Business Profile coordination (storm-area photo posting)
  • Accounts per account manager (where disclosed)
  • Reporting (live dashboard with insurance vs cash-pay segmentation)
  • Best company size fit (solo storm chaser vs multi-state retail)
  • Ownership structure (founder-owned vs PE-backed, account-team churn risk)

Source data: agency websites, public pricing pages, Clutch.co profiles, G2 reviews, BBB business profiles, Inc. 5000 listings, press releases, and the ~700 account roofing LSA benchmark dataset (median CPL $58, 28% booking rate, $12K avg ticket) published at /how-much-does-google-lsa-cost.

The Quick Read

TL;DR: 8 roofing Agencies Compared on 8 Critical Criteria

If you only have 60 seconds, this table covers what matters most: published pricing, contract length, free trial availability, LSA dispute filing policy, and best company size fit. Detailed reviews of each agency follow below.

# Agency Pricing Setup fee Contract Free trial LSA disputes filed Best for
1 Blue Grid Media $445 / $695 / $995 /mo $0 Month-to-month 30 days, no invoice Every disputable lead 1–10 crew roofers, $2.5K–$15K ad spend
2 RYNO Strategic Solutions Quote only Quote No-commitment (claimed) No Not publicly disclosed Mid–enterprise home services, full stack
3 Hook Agency $2K–$15.75K /mo Included in monthly Not publicly disclosed No Not publicly disclosed Mid-market roofing, multi-channel growth
4 Rival Digital From $1,200 /mo Quote Not publicly disclosed No Not publicly disclosed Boutique roofing/plumbing/electrical, high-touch
5 Scorpion $10K–$25K+ /mo $5K–$50K 12 months min No Not publicly disclosed Enterprise roofing, 15+ crews, $50K+ ad spend
6 Estes Media From $1,000 project min Quote Not publicly disclosed No Not publicly disclosed Mid-market residential + commercial roofing, content-led
7 Roofing Webmasters Quote only Quote Not publicly disclosed No Not publicly disclosed Solo–mid roofing, Roofing-only since 2012, DataPins tool
8 Built-Right Digital $750–$7,500 /mo Quote No long contracts No Not publicly disclosed Small–mid roofing, transparent pricing tiers

Verified May 2026. Pricing for non-published agencies based on public reviews and industry pricing guides. See methodology for sources.

Detailed Reviews

The 8 Agencies, Reviewed in Depth

Each review below covers what the agency does well, where it falls short, real pricing where published, and the specific roofing contractor size and situation it fits best. Pros and cons are written from the perspective of an roofing operator hiring an outside partner.

1

Blue Grid Media

Google Ads + LSA specialist · Home services agency

roofing specialist Founder-run 20-account cap
$445 / $695 / $995 /mo
LSA / Google Ads / Bundle

Blue Grid Media positions roofing as a two-business model (storm-restoration insurance work vs cash-pay retail repair) and runs them as two campaigns, two ad-copy systems, two bid strategies, and two landing pages. Storm event response within 24 hours of a hail trigger, insurance-claim-quality lead scoring, EagleView / RoofSnap aerial-measurement integration, and aggressive LSA dispute filing (roofing has the highest dispute volume of any home services trade). Pricing published transparently at $445 LSA / $695 Google Ads / $995 bundled. Month-to-month. 30-day free month before any invoice. Founder Blue Grid Media personally runs every roofing account under a hard 20-account-per-manager cap, which matters most during storm-season spikes when generalist agencies get overwhelmed. The 700-account roofing CPL benchmark dataset is at /roofing-lsa-cost-per-lead.

What works for roofing contractors

  • Dispute filing on every disputable LSA lead (roofing has the highest dispute volume of any trade; on a $5K/mo roofing LSA account this recovers $500–$1,500/mo in credits)
  • Storm + retail campaign separation by default (instead of one bucket lumping insurance work with cash-pay repairs)
  • Aerial measurement workflow integration (EagleView, RoofSnap call tracking + cost-per-square attribution)
  • Transparent flat-fee pricing published on the site, no setup fees, month-to-month
  • 30-day free month: zero invoice during the audit and rebuild period
  • 20-account cap per manager (founder-attended quality, important during storm-season spikes)
  • Published roofing CPL benchmark dataset (700 accounts, median $58 CPL, 28% booking rate) at /roofing-lsa-cost-per-lead

Where competitors beat them

  • Roofing Webmasters has deeper roofing-only specialization (since 2012, DataPins tool) and BGM is multi-trade
  • Hook Agency has stronger creative + website production capability for retail roofers
  • Built-Right Digital has lower entry pricing ($750/mo small markets) for solo storm chasers
  • 20-account cap limits scalability for multi-state retail roofing operators (Scorpion territory)
  • No in-house drone photography, video production, or branded creative
  • Does not offer broader services like SEO, web design, social media, or OTT
Best for: Retail and storm-restoration roofing contractors running 1–10 crews with $2,500–$15,000/mo in ad spend who want every disputable LSA lead filed (roofing's biggest hidden recovery), transparent pricing without storm-season setup fees, and storm vs retail campaign separation from day one. Not the right fit if you need a single agency to also handle SEO, drone photography, website rebuilds, OTT, or branded creative production.
2

RYNO Strategic Solutions

Home services digital marketing · Founded 2008 · Acquired by EverService 2023, merged with Blue Corona 2024

Full-stack agency PE-backed Proprietary RYNOtrax reporting
Quote only
Custom retainer model

RYNO Strategic Solutions is one of the largest home services digital marketing agencies in the US, formed from the 2024 merger between Blue Corona and RYNO and now operating under EverService ownership. Full digital stack: SEO, PPC, LSA, social, video production, OTT/geofencing, CSR coaching, and the proprietary RYNOtrax lead tracking platform. They serve hundreds of roofing contractors and consistently appear on industry "best roofing marketing agency" lists. Quote-only pricing; no published rates.

What works for roofing contractors

  • Deep home services specialization (roofing, plumbing, electrical, roofing)
  • Proprietary RYNOtrax platform tracks, qualifies, and classifies every lead
  • Full-stack: PPC + LSA + SEO + social + video + OTT under one roof
  • "No commitment, no contract" claimed on their partnership pages
  • Long track record (since 2008) with hundreds of roofing accounts
  • ServiceTitan marketplace partner integration

Where competitors beat them

  • Quote-only pricing; no transparent published rates for comparison
  • EverService PE ownership; potential for pricing drift and account manager churn
  • Account team depth varies after the Blue Corona merger
  • RYNOtrax is proprietary; data portability if you leave is unclear
  • No published free trial; standard quote-and-onboard model
Best for: Mid-to-enterprise home services contractors (roofing, plumbing, roofing) who want a single agency for everything from PPC and LSA to SEO, video production, and OTT campaigns. The full-stack pitch is the appeal. Not the right fit if you want transparent pricing upfront or a founder-attended account.

Not sure which tier of agency fits your roofing business?

Book a free 30-minute audit. We will open your LSA profile and Google Ads account live, identify exactly which agency tier ($500/mo flat, $2-5K/mo retainer, or $10K+/mo enterprise) matches your spend, and write you a 1-page recommendation. Even if you do not hire BGM.

Book Free Audit
3

Hook Agency

Roofing + HVAC marketing · Inc. 5000 #2031

Roofing + HVAC focus Founder-owned Multi-channel
$2K–$15.75K /mo
Scales with ad spend

Hook Agency built its reputation on home services marketing, particularly roofing and roofing, with $3M+ in annual revenue and a spot on the Inc. 5000 list at #2031. Three core service lines: website design, paid ads, and SEO. Pricing scales with monthly ad budget. Documented roofing case study with Aquarius (503% increase in engaged organic traffic, 416% boost in total keywords, 188% more first-page rankings in one year).

What works for roofing contractors

  • Multi-channel (website + paid + SEO) under one roof for mid-market growth
  • Strong creative production and website design capabilities
  • Published Inc. 5000 ranking and documented roofing case studies
  • Pricing scales transparently from $2K to ~$15.75K based on ad spend tier
  • Founder-owned, growth-focused culture

Where competitors beat them

  • Contract length not published on agency site (no transparent month-to-month)
  • No free trial; standard onboarding model
  • LSA dispute filing policy not featured on agency materials
  • Roofing case studies more numerous and detailed than roofing outcomes
  • Higher floor pricing ($2K/mo minimum) than BGM or Rival Digital
Best for: Mid-market roofing contractors ($1M–$5M annual revenue, 4+ crews) who want multi-channel growth and strong creative + website capabilities. Particularly strong if you also operate a roofing or storm-restoration line.
4

Rival Digital

Home services marketing · Boutique model · 85% HVAC / plumbing / electrical / roofing

Home services boutique Boutique High-touch
From $1,200 /mo
Custom retainers

Rival Digital is a boutique home services agency with 85% of its client base in roofing, plumbing, and electrical. They intentionally limit client volume to deliver higher-touch service. PPC campaigns built around local search terms that generate booked jobs (not vanity traffic). Notable roofing outcomes include American Vintage Home ($2.5M revenue with 77:1 ROI in first 8 months) and Hometown Plumbing (72% YoY qualified lead growth in year one).

What works for roofing contractors

  • 85% home services client base (deep trade specialization)
  • Boutique model with capped client load for high-touch service
  • Lower entry pricing (~$1,200/mo) than most full-service agencies
  • Strong documented case studies with named clients and revenue figures
  • PPC structured around booked-job outcomes, not click volume

Where competitors beat them

  • Quote-only pricing; no published rates on the site for comparison
  • No free trial; standard onboarding model
  • Limited public detail on LSA dispute filing policy
  • Smaller team than RYNO, Hook, or Scorpion
  • Less infrastructure for multi-location enterprise roofing operators
Best for: Single-location or 2-5 truck roofing operators who want boutique attention, documented case studies, and a lower entry price than full-service agencies. Particularly strong if you also have a plumbing or electrical division.
5

Scorpion

Enterprise home services marketing · PE-backed · Featured on the ACCA roofing Blog

Enterprise scale PE-backed Proprietary website platform
$10K–$25K+ /mo
Plus $5K–$50K setup

Scorpion is one of the largest home services marketing agencies in the US. Scorpion does not publish pricing on its website, so figures here come from third-party reviews (gorillawebtactics.com, intercore.net): monthly retainers reported at $10,000 to $25,000+, custom websites around $200,000, and setup fees of $5,000 to $50,000. The "RevenueMax" AI marketing suite is their flagship product. Standard contracts are 12-month minimums (also reported in third-party reviews). The Scorpion website platform is proprietary (not WordPress-based), which makes data portability challenging if you ever leave.

What works for roofing contractors

  • Enterprise-scale capacity for 50+ truck multi-location roofing operators
  • Deep account teams (dedicated AM, strategist, designer per account)
  • RevenueMax AI marketing suite with sophisticated reporting
  • Featured on the ACCA roofing Blog (Air Conditioning Contractors of America trade association)
  • Two decades of home services marketing experience

Where competitors beat them

  • Floor pricing of $10K/mo prices out 95% of roofing contractors
  • $5K–$50K setup fees on top of monthly retainer
  • 12-month minimum contracts are non-negotiable
  • Total first-year investment often exceeds $200,000
  • Proprietary website platform; migration requires rebuilding from scratch
  • PE ownership; account churn and pricing drift risks
Best for: Enterprise roofing operators with 15+ crews, $50,000+ monthly ad spend, multiple locations, and an in-house marketing director who can manage the agency relationship. Not the right fit for anyone running fewer than 8 crews or under $10K/mo ad spend.
6

Estes Media

Construction + roofing marketing · Jersey City, NJ · Semrush Agency Partner

Residential + commercial roofing Content-led Founder-owned
From $1,000 project min
Custom retainers

Estes Media is a full-service digital marketing agency based in Jersey City, NJ, with deep specialization in construction and roofing marketing. They build content-led marketing systems that combine SEO, PPC, email, and site design into a cohesive engine. Documented roofing case studies include a website redesign for one roofing company that increased organic traffic 61% and tripled form submissions, and a Chaffee Roofing engagement that generated over $1M in additional revenue. Minimum project size $1,000 (per Clutch profile); retainer pricing is custom.

What works for roofing contractors

  • Documented roofing case studies with named clients and revenue figures
  • Content-led approach pairs SEO + PPC + email under one strategy
  • Strong Clutch reviews (13+ ratings, mostly positive)
  • Both residential and commercial roofing capabilities
  • Semrush Agency Partner credentialing

Where competitors beat them

  • Full retainer pricing not published; minimum project size only
  • Smaller team than RYNO, Scorpion, or Hook
  • Contract length not publicly disclosed; no free trial
  • LSA dispute filing policy not featured in agency materials
  • Less paid-search-specific depth than dedicated PPC agencies
Best for: Mid-market roofing contractors who want a content-led marketing system (SEO + PPC + email + site design) rather than paid-search-only management. Particularly strong if you operate both residential and commercial roofing lines and want named case studies as buying proof.
7

Roofing Webmasters

100% Roofing-only digital marketing since 2012 · Fort Worth, TX · Proprietary DataPins tool

Roofing-only DataPins (proprietary) 1,000+ roofing companies served
Custom quote
Flat-fee structure

Roofing Webmasters has been 100% roofing-exclusive since 2012, with firsthand experience across 1,000+ roofing companies. They offer a full stack: SEO, Google Ads, lead generation systems, conversion optimization, custom web design, GBP management, content writing, and reputation management. Their proprietary differentiator is DataPins, a system that lets roofers tag completed jobs with photos, descriptions, and geo-coordinates directly on their websites to automatically create location-specific content and automate review requests via SMS and email. Pricing is custom (flat-fee structure stated, but no public rate card).

What works for roofing contractors

  • 100% roofing-exclusive focus since 2012 (deepest roofing specialization in this list)
  • 1,000+ roofing accounts served, deep understanding of seasonality and trade keywords
  • Proprietary DataPins tool automates job-site content + review requests
  • Stated flat-fee pricing structure (aligned incentives with client outcomes)
  • Full digital stack under one agency (SEO + Ads + web + reputation)

Where competitors beat them

  • No public pricing rate card despite "flat-fee" positioning
  • DataPins is proprietary; data portability if you leave is unclear
  • Heavier on SEO/GBP than paid-search-first agencies
  • LSA dispute filing policy not publicly disclosed
  • Smaller team than RYNO, Scorpion, or Hook
Best for: Roofing contractors who want the deepest Roofing-only specialization on the market, a proprietary tool (DataPins) that automates location-specific content + review collection, and a single agency for the entire digital stack. Particularly strong if SEO and GBP are your primary growth channels rather than paid ads only.
8

Built-Right Digital

Home services + roofing growth partner · Transparent published pricing tiers

Roofing-focused Published pricing No long contracts
$750–$7,500+ /mo
By market size

Built-Right Digital is a roofing-focused growth agency with one of the most transparent published pricing structures in this list. Small-market roofers can start at $750-$1,500/mo, multi-city campaigns run $1,500-$3,500/mo, and major-metro operators in Houston, Atlanta, Phoenix typically need $3,500-$7,500+/mo. Services span Google Ads, LSA, conversion-optimized web design, hyper-focused local SEO, and Meta Ads. Clutch profile shows 11 reviews with documented results including a client whose cost-per-lead dropped 15% and click-through rates improved 25% within the first month. Their stated policy is no long contracts with performance benchmarks, though they recommend sustaining budget for at least 12 months because SEO compounds.

What works for roofing contractors

  • Most transparent published pricing structure on the list (by market size)
  • No long-term contracts policy
  • Roofing-focused with documented Clutch reviews and case results
  • Full stack: Google Ads + LSA + Meta + SEO + web design
  • Reasonable entry pricing ($750/mo small market) accessible to solo operators

Where competitors beat them

  • Newer / smaller than RYNO, Scorpion, Hook, or Roofing Webmasters
  • LSA dispute filing policy not publicly disclosed
  • No free trial; standard onboarding model
  • Less roofing-exclusive than Roofing Webmasters (also serves other home services)
  • Accounts-per-manager ratio not publicly disclosed
Best for: Solo or 1-3 crew roofing contractors in small-to-mid markets who want transparent pricing tiers, no long-term contracts, and a full digital stack at accessible entry prices. Particularly strong if you are price-sensitive and want to verify costs before any conversation.
Full Comparison Matrix

14 Criteria, Side by Side

For buyers who want every line item compared in one view. Sortable by criterion; we recommend reading top to bottom. "Yes" means the service is included in standard pricing; "Add-on" means it costs extra; "No" means not offered.

Criterion BGM RYNO Hook Rival Scorpion Estes Media Roofing Webmasters Built-Right Digital
Published pricingYesNoYesNoNoProject min onlyNoYes
Pricing modelFlat feeCustom retainerTiered by spendCustom retainerCustom retainerCustom retainerFlat-fee (stated)Tiered by market
Setup fees$0QuoteIncludedQuote$5K–$50KQuoteQuoteQuote
Contract lengthMonth-to-monthNo-commitment claimedNot disclosedCustom12 mo minNot disclosedNot disclosedNo long contracts
Free trial30 daysNoNoNoNoNoNoNo
Roofing specializationSpecialistHome servicesRoofing + HVACHome servicesHome servicesConstruction + roofingRoofing-only (since 2012)Roofing-focused
Google Ads managementFeaturedFeaturedFeaturedFeaturedFeaturedFeaturedFeaturedFeatured
LSA managementFeaturedFeaturedYesYesYesAvailableYesYes
LSA dispute filing policyEvery disputable lead (published policy)Not publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosed
GBP coordinationIncludedIncludedIncludedAdd-onIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Accounts per manager20 max (published)Not publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedCapped (boutique, exact number not published)Not publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosed
ReportingLive dashboardRYNOtraxMonthly + dashboardCustom reportsRevenueMax AICustom + Semrush partnerCustom + DataPinsMonthly + dashboard
Best company size1–10 crew roofersMid–enterpriseMid-marketSolo–smallEnterpriseMid-marketSolo–midSmall–mid
OwnershipFounder-ownedPE-backed (EverService)Founder-ownedFounder-ownedPE-backedFounder-ownedFounder-ownedFounder-owned

"Available" or "Add-on" indicates the service exists but is not part of standard pricing. "Limited" indicates the service is offered but not featured prominently in agency materials.

Want this comparison applied to your specific roofing situation?

We will open your current LSA profile and Google Ads account live during a 30-minute call, identify the agency tier and pricing model that fits your spend, and write you a 1-page recommendation. Free, no contract required, even if you ultimately pick a different agency.

Book Free 30-min Call
Buyer's Guide

6 Questions Every Roofer Should Ask Before Signing

Roofing has tighter season-to-season cash flow than any other home services trade, and contract terms hit harder when storm volume dips. These 6 questions surface answers that matter more for roofing than for any other vertical, ask them before any agency signature.

1. What's your storm event playbook?

Roofing demand spikes 200–400% in hail-affected metros within 24–72 hours of a storm. Ask: "What's your default response when a hail event hits one of my metros? Show me a recent example with timestamps." Agencies without a pre-built protocol will fumble the most profitable 30 days of your year.

BGM, Hook, Roofing Webmasters, Built-Right Digital have storm protocols

2. How do you separate storm from retail campaigns?

Insurance-claim storm work and cash-pay retail repair behave like two different businesses (different keywords, ad copy, landing pages, even sales scripts). Lumping them into one campaign gives you average results on both. Ask to see the campaign structure before you sign.

Specialist agencies separate by default

3. Do you file every disputable LSA lead?

Roofing has the highest LSA dispute volume of any home services trade because of storm-area address bleed, insurance-vs-cash confusion, and out-of-territory storm chasers. On a $5K/mo roofing LSA spend, aggressive dispute filing recovers $500–$1,500/mo. Agencies that say "you can file yourself" are skipping the work.

BGM publishes this policy; others do not disclose

4. What contract length and seasonal exit terms?

Roofing is the most seasonal home services trade after landscaping. A 12-month contract signed in spring locks you into management fees during winter slow months. Ask: "Can I pause or scale down spend during shoulder seasons without leaving the contract?"

BGM, Built-Right Digital, RYNO offer flexibility

5. Do you integrate aerial measurement tools?

EagleView, RoofSnap, Hover, and similar measurement platforms feed real square-footage data into your CPA math. Agencies that integrate them report cost-per-square accurately; ones that don't optimize on vanity metrics. Ask which platforms they pull from.

Roofing specialists almost universally integrate one

6. How do you handle insurance-claim-quality leads?

An insurance-claim replacement ($8K–$25K) is worth 8–30x a cash repair ($300–$1,200). But insurance work also has longer sales cycles and higher dispute volume. Ask: "How do you score insurance-eligible leads differently and how does your bid strategy reflect that?"

Hook, Roofing Webmasters, Built-Right Digital have documented playbooks

Hail Season Is the Wrong Time to Hire a Generalist.

Roofing accounts have the highest LSA dispute volume of any home services trade (storm-area address bleed, insurance-vs-cash-pay confusion, out-of-territory storm chasers). The only free 30-day trial in this comparison: we take over your LSA profile and Google Ads account, fix the campaigns, file every disputable lead, and recover the credits you've been leaving on the table. At day 30 you decide if the work is worth $445/$695/$995/mo. Zero invoice during the trial.

Claim My Free Month
FAQ

Roofing Marketing Agency FAQ

How much does a roofing Google Ads agency cost in 2026?

Roofing agency fees split into three tiers. Small-market (1–3 crews, sub-metro): $750–$2,000/mo, Built-Right Digital and BGM cover this band. Mid-market (multi-city, 3–10 crews): $1,500–$5,000/mo, BGM, Hook, Rival, Built-Right, and Estes Media cluster here. Enterprise + multi-state ($5K+ ad spend): $5,000–$25,000+/mo, Scorpion and RYNO dominate. Storm-season tip: agencies charging a percentage of ad spend silently profit from your storm-month spikes. Flat-fee models (BGM $445/$695/$995) flatten that cash-flow risk.

Should I hire a generalist agency or a roofing specialist?

Specialists win on tactical depth: campaign structure, seasonal bid pacing, storm season bid pacing and hail event response, insurance claim quality leads vs cash-pay separation, maintenance plan acquisition, storm restoration window timing. Generalists win on scale: more services under one roof, larger account teams, broader case study libraries. For roofing contractors with $2K–$15K monthly ad spend, a specialist (BGM, Rival Digital, Roofing Webmasters) usually outperforms. For enterprise roofing operators with 15+ crews and $50K+ monthly spend, a large generalist (Scorpion or RYNO) may serve better.

What's the difference between Google Ads management and LSA management for roofers?

For roofers, the two channels behave very differently. Google Ads: CPC range $30–$100+ per click, the highest of any home services trade. Keyword targeting matters (storm repair vs full replacement vs commercial vs metal roofing produce 3-10x cost differences). Storm-season bid pacing can swing 200–400% in 72 hours. LSA: median $58 CPL for roofing ($35–$120 range), 28% lead-to-booked-job conversion. The dispute volume is the highest of any trade in Google's home services catalog because of storm-area address bleed and insurance-vs-cash confusion. Half the agencies on this list manage both at depth; the rest treat one as a secondary line. Ask to see a sample of each before signing.

Do all 8 agencies file LSA disputes for their roofing clients?

Roofing has the highest LSA dispute rate of any home services trade. Three reasons: storm-area address bleed (homeowners in the disaster zip but outside your service radius), insurance-vs-cash confusion (homeowner thinks insurance will cover, finds out it won't, never books), and storm chaser interference (out-of-state operators flooding the same metro). Despite that, only Blue Grid Media publishes its dispute filing policy publicly: every disputable lead inside Google's 30-day window. The other 7 agencies don't disclose policy on their websites. On a $5,000/mo roofing LSA account, aggressive dispute filing recovers $500–$1,500/mo, which often determines effective CPL more than keyword work. Ask any agency in writing: "Will you file every disputable lead by default, or only ones I flag?"

How long should I expect to be locked into a contract?

Contract length is one of the least transparent line items. Blue Grid Media, RYNO Strategic Solutions (claimed), and Roofing Webmasters offer month-to-month or no-contract arrangements. Scorpion's standard contract is 12 months minimum with significant setup fees ($5K–$50K), confirmed in multiple third-party reviews. Hook Agency, Rival Digital, Estes Media, and Built-Right Digital do not publicly disclose their default contract length (Built-Right Digital states a no-long-contracts policy but does not specify default term). Industry-typical for full-service home services agencies is 6–12 months, but ask any agency for their specific terms in writing.

What's the average cost per lead for roofing on Google?

Median roofing LSA CPL is $58 with a range of $35–$120, based on a ~700 account roofing benchmark dataset at /roofing-lsa-cost-per-lead. Google Ads CPL for roofing runs higher at $100–$300 depending on storm season and metro competition. Booking rate averages 28% (lower than HVAC's 38% because of insurance-claim sales-cycle drag), so effective cost per booked job lands around $200–$350. With replacement jobs averaging $12,000 in ticket size, the LTV multiple is 35-60x. Storm-season metro CPLs can spike 2-3x in the first 72 hours after a hail event, so cost discipline matters most when volume is highest.

Which agency is best for a small roofing business with $2K–$5K monthly ad spend?

For small roofing (1–3 crews, $2K–$5K monthly ad spend), the strongest fits are Blue Grid Media (transparent $445/$695/$995 pricing, 30-day free trial, month-to-month), Built-Right Digital (transparent $750-$7,500/mo range), and Rival Digital (boutique, ~$1,200/mo, 85% home services client base). Hook Agency starts at $2,000/mo for sub-$5K ad budgets. Scorpion has confirmed minimum ad spend of $5K–$15K/mo plus $5K–$50K setup fees, which excludes most small operators. Built-Right Digital starts as low as $750/mo for small markets, scaling to $7,500+/mo for major metros, giving it broad coverage across roofing operator sizes.

Should I worry about an agency being acquired by private equity?

Yes, but selectively. Two agencies on this list have PE or roll-up exposure: RYNO Strategic Solutions (acquired by EverService April 2023, merged with Blue Corona 2024) and Scorpion (PE-backed). Risks: account manager churn, pricing drift, proprietary platform lock-in. Benefits: capital for tooling, reporting infrastructure, case studies. For small-to-mid-market roofing, founder-owned agencies (BGM, Hook, Rival Digital, Roofing Webmasters, Built-Right Digital, Estes Media) typically deliver better continuity.

Why is Blue Grid Media ranked first?

Disclosure: Blue Grid Media publishes this comparison and the criteria were locked before scoring, listed in the methodology section. For roofing specifically, BGM scores highest because of the trade-weighted criteria: (a) published dispute filing policy in a trade with the highest LSA dispute volume of any home services category, (b) storm vs retail campaign separation by default rather than as an upsell, (c) transparent flat-fee pricing that flattens storm-season cash-flow volatility (vs % of spend that profits from your hail-event spikes), (d) published 700-account roofing CPL dataset at /roofing-lsa-cost-per-lead, and (e) the only 30-day free trial in this comparison. Where competitors beat BGM (Roofing Webmasters' DataPins tool, Hook's creative production, Built-Right Digital's lower entry pricing, Scorpion's enterprise scale), those cases are listed honestly in each agency's review card above.

How often is this comparison updated?

Reviewed quarterly with an additional storm-season check every March-April (the peak hail window for the Midwest and Plains) when agency capacity often gets reshuffled. Pricing, contract terms, ownership changes, and trade-specific service updates (new dispute-policy disclosures, aerial-measurement integrations, DataPins-style proprietary tools) are updated whenever a public source indicates a change. Verification date is shown at the top of the page. Outdated information? Send corrections via /contact and we verify within 5 business days.

Roofers ready to decide

Before You Sign with Any Roofing Agency, Get a 1-Page Diagnostic

30-minute live screen-share. We open your LSA profile and Google Ads account, identify how many disputable leads went unfiled in the last 60 days, flag your storm-season bid pacing gaps, and write you a 1-page recommendation that compares BGM to any other roofing agency on this list. Even if the recommendation points you to a competitor.

Book Your Free Roofing Diagnostic